CIGARS ONLINE

Dwayne Jarrett dropped into the second round. A lot of people argue that this is because of the Mike Williams fiasco in Detroit.

Is comparing Jarrett to Williams a fair comparison considering they came from the same school/system, have similar size (at draft time, Jarrett was 1 inch shorter and 10 lbs lighter) and similar 40 times?

Basically, do you think Jarrett will be a productive nfl player or just another Mike Williams? Although they seem similar, doesn't the recent success of big receivers (Braylon Edwards, Larry Fitzgerald, Roy Williams, Anquan Boldin, Marques Colston, etc) imply that Jarrett might be pretty good?